English | 中文版 |  Русский

Breaking News:

Read our Asia Exclusive Material

Source: www.asiaecon.org |

China's New Anti-Monopoly Law is Anti-Competitive


China's government passed its own version of competition policy (anti-trust law) to take effect on 1 August 2008.1 Anti-monopoly laws are, on the surface, designed to protect consumers from producers that attempt to gain monopoly power in a market, and then leverage this power at the cost of consumers. China's…


China’s government passed its own version of competition policy (anti-trust law) to take effect on 1 August 2008.1  Anti-monopoly laws are, on the surface, designed to protect consumers from producers that attempt to gain monopoly power in a market, and then leverage this power at the cost of consumers.  China’s new law, however, limits competition in one of the most important markets in any industrialized economy: the management market or market for corporate control.

In the market for corporate control, the managers of corporations are the producers, and the stockholders are the consumers.  If a corporation is owned by stockholders, but controlled by hired managers, the managers have an opportunity to divert corporate resources for the managers’ purposes rather than serving the interests of the stockholders and maximizing profits.  However, if a team of managers diverts stockholder resources, the price of the stock will fall.  When the price falls, an opportunity is created for other management teams to purchase the company for less than its assets are potentially worth, and make a profit by managing the resources better.  The potential corporate raiders thus discipline the managers and prevent them from misallocating resources.2

A perfectly competitive market for corporate control prevents <i>any</i> misallocation of resources.  However, as this market becomes less competitive, opportunities arise for managers to steal from owners.  China’s new law makes this market much less competitive.  Of course, all anti-monopoly laws make the market for corporate control less competitive, because they limit mergers from the managers that have the most expertise to run a company in a particular industry: the company’s competitors in that industry.  Whether or not this is offset by increased competitiveness in other markets is a debatable issue.  However, China’s nationalistic tinge on their competition policy exacerbates this problem. 

The new law stipulates that, “Foreign acquisitions of Chinese companies will be subject to stringent new checks intended to protect China’s economic security under a new competition law passed on Thursday.”3  This new law will, at the very least, act like an import control law in any market and will make it more expensive for “imported management” to enter the market for corporate control.  It will likely create a small cartel of qualified Chinese managers in each specialized industrial market.  These managers will be able to mismanage the resources of middle-class investors without the fear of “Barbarians at the Gates” glancing at their balance sheets with opportunism in their eyes.

Despite the assurances of Mei Xinyu of the Chinese Academy of International Trade and Economic Cooperation4, foreign direct investment will be affected by the new law, especially in the long run.  While current plans to invest in China may continue, once Chinese managers begin to enjoy the impunity of their new law, they will begin to shirk.  Corporate scandals will inevitably follow.  Based on recent history, the government will likely prosecute individuals instead of examining root problems in the system.  However, even those managers that do not engage in brazenly corrupt activity will still receive higher compensation (in the form of both salary and perks) than they would without the law to protect them.  Some investment that would go to China will go elsewhere.

There may be some good that comes out of this new law however.  If the government of China feels more secure because of the new law, they may be more willing to further privatize its economy.  Despite the new regulations and shirking managers, these newly privatized industries will be more efficient than they ever could be if controlled by the government.

Source: www.asiaecon.org |

 

Comments

No comments yet


Log in to leave a comment


About Exclusives

AEI publishes Exclusives, an original online publication on topics concerning international business, specifically Asia. All issues of the Exclusives are available for free. Exclusives maintains the highest level of scholarly integrity. Therefore, AEI is quite flexible in terms of the style and approach of prospective authors and does not seek to influence authors in their topic choice and encourages provocative yet substantive submissions. Exclusives are published periodically when an appropriate number of articles have been received, reviewed and approved. This has generally been about one issue per month, but varies as events of interest happen and seasonal fluctuations in submissions occur. All published articles are original works based on the research and analysis of the author. Publication of an opinion or viewpoint within Exclusives doesn't reflect endorsement by the AEI. Because an official Institute-wide position would interfere with the intellectual independence of individual scholars and journalists, AEI takes no institutional positions on policy issues or attempts to influence legislative bodies.

Exclusives FAQ

Can anyone submit an article ?

Yes. We are open to submissions from anyone. AEI Editors make their article selections based on the quality of content and insightfulness of the prospective authors, not their institutional affiliations.

Are there formatting requirements for submission ?

Yes. See the Submission Guidelines page for details.

Can I put an Exclusives article on my resume/CV ?

Yes. Although we are not a peer-reviewed academic journal we do review and edit submissions and maintain high standards for publication.

Is the Exclusives referenced by academic indexing or database services ?

No. Not at this time.

Are contributors paid for their Exclusive articles ?

No. Paying contributors is not in the academic spirit of this publication.

Can I reprint my Exclusives article in another publication at a later time ?

Yes, but you must obtain permission from AEI to have your Exclusives article reprinted in another publication. Also, permission must be obtained each time you seek to republish the article. If permission to republish is granted, AEI must be given credit.

Who owns the Copyright for a published Exclusives article ?

Asia Economic Institute owns the copyright in any article you write for the AEI Exclusives.